Created by Ms. McCandlish
English Department
Fall 2003
“I’ll just tell you about this madman stuff
that happened to me around last Christmas just before I got pretty run-down and
had to come out here and take it easy.” In
the introduction of J.D. Salinger’s The
Catcher in the Rye, Holden Caulfield begins to narrate his story to a
psychoanalyst at a medical treatment center.
The Catcher in the Rye is a bildungsroman, or coming of age novel, about the emotional challenges and
feelings of depression that Holden experiences as he grows up in
Do you have any friends or
family members who are depressed?
Depression among teenagers in the
Your panel group will
study the problems of depression, feeling of sadness and helplessness found in
today’s teens. Using the TIPS Public Policy Analyst you will develop specific suggestions
for policies that might better deal with this problem. Your report may well bring about
changes that can really improve life for teens in the
In groups of three students, you will all assume the
roles of distinguished school psychologists.
Your group has been selected to analyze the causes and effects of
depression among teenagers, while proposing new solutions for preventing
depression in Bronx High Schools. Please
help save our students from feelings of sadness and helplessness!
1.
Each group member will be responsible for completing the public
policy analyst (PPA) worksheets, hyperlinked below. Write your answers to each worksheet on
your own separate sheets of paper, to be turned in to me!
2.
Using quotes and statistics gathered from the websites below,
each member of your team will write a five-paragraph research report that
determines the causes of teen depression, analyzes current policies to treat
depression, and proposes the best solutions to solve the problem of depression
in Bronx High Schools. (See Rubric #1 below)
3.
Your report should include a bibliography page of at least 3 of
the websites you research, using proper
citation format.
(Write the answers to the worksheets on your own separate paper, to be turned in for a grade with the research paper!)
1.
Begin by defining the problem the social problem presented to
you in the introduction.
2.
Gather the evidence from the websites below about teenagers
suffering from depression.
3.
Identify the causes of teenage depression.
4.
Evaluate the policy. What
are the current solutions to deal with teenage depression?
5.
Develop solutions. What new
solutions can your team propose to confront the problem of depression in Bronx
High Schools?
6.
Select the best policy. What is the best specific policy to deal
with depression in Bronx High Schools?
This is a new policy that your group creates themselves!
7.
Using the worksheets and your website research, write your
five-paragraph research paper on teenage depression. See outline below.
(Use quotes and statistics from at
least three websites to write your five-paragraph essay. Be sure to include
those sources in your bibliography page!)
AVOID PLAGIARISM! Put research into own words or use
quotations.
Consult
the TIPS website for further information about the Public Policy Analyst steps:
http://www.maxwell.syr.edu/plegal/TIPS/intro.html
Websites to
Research:
“Adolescent Depression: Helping Depressed Teens” http://www.nmha.org/infoctr/factsheets/24.cfm
“Alternative Solutions to Depression” http://www.webheights.net/depression/home.htm
“Campus Solutions to Depression” http://orion.csuchico.edu/Pages/Vol45issue2/dimensions/d.3.depression.html
“Causes of Depression” http://www.pfizerforwomen.com/hc_mhealth_b03.asp?mhealth
“Depression and Children” http://www.nmha.org/children/children_mh_matters/depression.cfm
“Depression: Learn about the Condition” http://www.pfizerforwomen.com/hc_mhealth_b03.asp?mhealth
“Depression Reality: Information and Support” http://www.bestsitez.com/depression/
“Depression Solutions: The Uplift Program” http://www.upliftprogram.com/
“Facts about Teenage Depression” http://www.depressedteens.com/facts.html
“Focus Adolescent Services” http://www.focusas.com/NewYork.html
“High School
SOS” http://www.mentalhealthscreening.org/sos_highschool/index.htm
“Montefiore School Health Centers” http://montekids.org/programs/school/
“More Teens Struggling with Depression” http://www.hon.ch/News/HSN/510926.html
“Promoting Children’s Mental Health” http://www.nmha.org/children/children_mh_matters/promoting.cfm
“Teenage Depression” http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/classic/A270109
“Teenage Depression: What Parents Can Do”
“What is Depression?” http://www.kidshealth.org/teen/your_mind/mental_health/depression.html
“What
is Major Depression?” http://montekids.org/healthlibrary/peds/mentalhealth/major.htm
1. Five-Paragraph Research Paper
Quality |
A (5) |
B (4) |
C (3) |
D (2) |
F (1) |
Meaning
& Development |
-Excellent
use of facts, quotes, and statistics from websites. -Fully
developed, 5-paragraph research paper that follows task. |
-Very
good demonstration of quotes and statistics from the web. -Well-developed
5-paragraph paper that follows task. |
-Average
use of quotes and statistics from websites. -Average
development of 5-paragraph paper. |
-Poor or
incorrect use of quotes and statistics from websites. -Poor
development of paper; has less than 5 paragraphs. |
-No use of
quotes and statistics or plagiarized from websites. -No
development -Paper
has only 3 paragraphs or less. |
Organization |
-Excellent
focus. -Paragraph
organization perfectly follows task. |
-Very
strong focus. -Paragraph
organization appropriately follows task. |
-Average
focus. -Average
organization of paragraphs -Some
awareness of task. |
-Lacks
focus. -Paragraphs
lack organization and awareness of task. |
-No
focus. -No
organization. -No
awareness of task. |
Language
& Conventions |
-Excellent
vocabulary. -Varies
sentence structure and length. -Perfect
grammar, spelling, and paragraphs. |
-Strong
vocabulary. -Good
variety of sentences. -Very
good grammar, spelling, and paragraphs. |
-Average
vocabulary. -Average
variety of sentences. -Average
grammar, spelling, and paragraphs. |
-Poor
vocabulary. -Poor
variety of sentences. -Poor
use of grammar, spelling, and paragraphs. |
-No
attention to vocabulary usage. -No
variety in sentence structure. -Incorrect
grammar, spelling, and paragraphs. |
Format |
6-step
Public Policy Analyst (PPA) format followed perfectly. |
PPA
format mostly followed. |
PPA
format followed Inconsistently. |
Little
or confused understanding of PPA format. |
No use
of PPA format. |
GRADE KEY:
A= 18-20 B
=15-17 C=12-14 D=8-11 F=4-7
a |
Read twenty-five books of the
quality and complexity illustrated in the sample reading list. |
c |
Read and comprehend
informational materials. |
Writing
a |
Produce a report of information. |
e |
Produce a persuasive essay. |
Speaking, Listening, and Viewing
a |
Participate in one-to-one
conferences with the teacher. |
b |
Participate in group meetings. |
c |
Prepare and deliver an
individual presentation. |
Conventions, Grammar, and Usage of the
English Language
a |
Independently and habitually demonstrate
an understanding of the rules of the English |
b |
Analyze and subsequently revise work
to improve its clarity and effectiveness. |
Public Documents
a |
Critique public documents with
an eye to strategies common in public discourse. |
b |
Produce public documents. |
Functional Documents
a |
Critique functional documents
with an eye to strategies common to effective functional documents. |
b |
Produce functional documents
appropriate to audience and purpose. |
Information Tools and Techniques
a |
Gather information to assist in completing project work. |
b |
Use on-line sources to exchange information for specific
purposes. |
c |
Use word-processing software to produce a multi-page document. |
d |
Write, add content to, and analyze a relational data base. |
Tools and Techniques for Working With
Others
a |
Participate in the establishment and operation of
self-directed work teams. |
Putting
Mathematics to Work
a |
Data
study. |
Congratulations! Upon your successful completion of this web
quest, you have researched and analyzed the social problem of teenage
depression using the TIPS Public Policy Analyst
guidelines. Through this web quest,
you analyzed the causes and effects of depression on teenagers. Your group reviewed current public policy
solutions to teenage depression, while creating your own new solutions for
preventing depression in our own Bronx High Schools. You have learned to develop a five-paragraph
research report using websites for evidence and information to complete your
task.
Hopefully,
you all developed some creative solutions to prevent depression in Bronx High
Schools. Perhaps your solutions would
also help save Holden Caulfield from depression, just like he wants to save all
the children as the catcher in the rye.