Ms.
Bisguier
Kenneth
Gaskins, Principal
Junior
English
Webquest:
Red
Scare McCarthyism and
Arthur
Miller’s
The Crucible
Table of Contents:
Introduction
Task
Research Questions Worksheet
Print Resources
Online Resources/Weblinks
Process
JournalisMatters
Evaluation/Rubrics
N.Y.C. Standards / N.Y.S. Regents Themes
Conclusion: Works Cited
Introduction Introduction Introduction:
-The time is the 1950s. You are a hot-shot reporter (or if you choose,
columnist or editorialist) for a respectable newspaper, and you are covering
the story of a lifetime.
-The story you are onto is the one Arthur Miller
was commenting on in his allegorical play, The Crucible. In
this story, intolerance and hysteria (two
major themes in
The
Crucible ) threaten the American
public.
-Your
burning assignment is to use the power of your pen to alert the public to the
dangers of Red-Scare–McCarthyism.
Your
TASK
-Your newspaper’s editor has asked you, an
expert on the Public
Policy Analyst, to use the P.P.A. to
show harms threatened by the specter of Red-Scare–McCarthyism. In a series of newspaper articles (or, if you
prefer, editorials or columns), you must expose the danger of one of these social problems.
The Process
: How to Carry
Out the Task
500: Points Total
In preparing your newspaper stories, you will
need to
·
research the era using the links and resources—listed below under resources
· answer the research questions--listed below under research questions—in full sentences on a separate
sheet of paper which must be handed in 150 points
·
read through the links to the Public Policy Analyst or P.P.A. –listed under process
·
with
your group choose and define a social
problem to report on specifically—Define a social problem is the first
of the six P.P.A. worksheets listed under process
50 points
·
with
your group complete the
remaining five (of six) worksheets
of the P.P.A.
50 points
·
by
yourself write a series of (at
least four) newspaper articles ( reporting on aspects of the social problem you have (with your group)
chosen to become experts on.
§
You
will want to consult the section
of this webquest entitled JournalisMatters for following the conventions of journalistic style.
200 points
·
present your material to the class using both
text and a chart, map, timeline, graph or other visual (as you are asked to on
Task II of your E.L.A. Regents Examination)
50 points
Find
rubrics for how the points specifically will be allotted for
the newspaper articles and presentation under the evaluation
section of this webquest.
Research Questions Worksheet:
Research
Questions
(150 points total)
to
complete in conjunction with Ms. Bisguier’sThe Crucible / Red Scare Webquest
Directions:
1. Read Chapter 17 of Prentice Hall’s Pathways (pp. 560-581).
2. Focus on Section 4: The
Cold War in the
3. Respond to the following
questions in full sentences.
These
research questions are adapted from Section 4 Review
on p. 581 and Chapter Review: Chapter 17, pp.
582-583.
Section 4
Review
(25 points total/5 points
each)
1.
Identify
a.
Alger
Hiss
b.
Julius
and Ethel Rosenberg
c.
Joseph
R. McCarthy
2. Why did Harry Truman
launch his Federal Employee Loyalty Program?
3. What was the HUAC and why
did it make
4. How did Senator McCarthy
create an atmosphere of suspicion and paranoia in the
5. HUAC forced Americans to
answer the question “Are you now or have you ever been a member of the
Communist party?” What assumptions was
this question based on?
Chapter Review
(30 points total/2 points
each)
1.
cold
war
2. proletariat
3. totalitarian
4. iron curtain
5. United Nations
6. containment
7. Truman Doctrine
8. Marshall Plan
9.
10. NATO
11. NSC-68
12. satellite nation
13. 38th parallel
14. domino theory
15. 17th parallel
For
each term above, write a
sentence that explains its
relation to the post-
World-War-II
period.
Reviewing Main
Ideas
Section 1
(pp. 562-565)
(6
points/3 points each)
1.
Describe
the relationship between the
2. Why did the
Section 2
(pp. 567-581)
(6
points/3 points each)
1.
Summarize
the policy of containment pursued by the
2. How were the Truman
doctrine, the
Section 4
(pp. 577-581) (15 points/5 points each)
1.
What
were the purpose and effects of Truman’s Federal Employee Loyalty Program?
2. What accusations did HUAC
make against the nineteen
3. What impact did Senator
McCarthy’s anticommunist crusade have on American society?
Thinking
Critically
(18 points/6 points each)
a.
Making
Comparisons
You have read about the different political and economic ideas that motivated
the
b.
Drawing
Conclusions
During the cold war, fear and hostility toward
communism were the driving forces behind many of the social and foreign
policies in the Unites States. How much
of this fear actually was grounded in reality?
c.
Identifying
Alternatives Imagine
that you are an adviser to President Eisenhower. The President has asked you to draw up a list
of alternatives to help him decide on his policy about the emerging conflict in
Making
Connections
(50 points in total for
this part of the project)
Writing About
the Chapter You have been accused by HUAC of participating in a communist
conspiracy.
·
Write a statement in which you defend
yourself against these charges.
·
First
create a list of the reasons why the accusation
is false. (10 points)
·
Note ways in
which the anticommunist hysteria of the times
has contributed to your false accusation. (10
points)
·
Then
write a draft
of your statement in which you respectfully but firmly defend yourself. (10 points)
·
Revise your statement, making certain that each point is clearly explained. Hand in your rough draft along with your final typed
copy. (20 points)
Print Resources Print Resources Print:
What’s black and white and read all over?
Ms. Bisguier’s Red Scare Newspaper Project
Textbook/Print
Resources:
Boyer et al. The
Enduring Vision.
Chapter 29 “
Especially for Horror Flicks and the Cold War,
Hollywood, Popular Culture, Movies, Television, Mass Media
Harold Evans’ The American Century
Special Topics from
Chapter 11, “
·
“The Pumpkin File” pp. 416-417.
·
“Ambassador of Paranoia,” pp. 418-419
·
“A Communist Gamble on
·
“Two Police States” p. 420
·
“The Dirtiest Campaign” 430-431
·
“Naughty Naughty,” (political cartoon by Herblock) p.430
·
“The
·
“The Thought Police” p. 441
·
“The Guilt of Julius Rosenberg” pp. 442-443
·
“The Venona Cables” p. 443
·
“The Rise of a Demagogue” pp. 444-445
·
“McCarthy Meets His Match” pp. 446-447
·
“Roy Cohn’s Second Scandalous Career” p. 447
·
“The Ordeal of Robert Oppenheimer” pp. 448-449
Bowes, et al .eds.The Americans,
Unit 7 “World War II, Causes and Consequences,”
1933-1960
Especially,
Chapter 30 1945-1956,
“Postwar period, Cold War, Korean War,” pp.766-791
Chapter 31 1950-1960, “Adjustments to the
1950s,” pp.792-818
Glencoe’s The American Vision
Chapter 26: The Cold War Begins
Especially,
·
section 3 “The Cold War and American Society,” pp. 790-796
Chapter 27: Postwar
Especially,
·
section 3 “Popular Culture of the 1950s,” pp.820-827
EMC Paradigm’sLiterature
and the Language Arts
Unit 10 Postwar Literature (1945-1960) pp.
758-764
Online Resources/Weblinks:
Use
the following online resources to help answer the questions on the worksheet (150 points) and to prepare the special topic of your Public
Policy Analysis research for reportage
and presentation.
http://www.moderntimes.com/palace/huac.htm
http://www.washington.edu/uwired/outreach/cspn/curcan/main.html#time
http://www.cnn.com/SPECIALS/cold.war/episodes/06/documents/huac/
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/database/kazan_e.html
http://teachers.sduhsd.net/mcunningham/why_i_wrote.htm
Using The TIPS WorkSheets
Use
these hyperlinks to access the six worksheets (100 points) of the PPA (The Public Policy Analyst):
· The
· Hysteria in the
· Cold War Terror
and Scary Movies
· Events in the
Rise of Joseph McCarthy
· Proceedings of
HUAC
· The Cold War
and at Home and Abroad
· Elia Kazan and
Arthur Miller: Rivalry and Betrayal
· Television and
Truth
· Prosperity and
Fear in Post-War
Journalism Matters :
Direct news leads are used on hard news
stories—stories about timely, breaking news. The first one or two paragraphs, the lead,
give the most important facts about a story.
s and one
The following and other useful journalism terms
may be found on page 114 of Journalism
Matters.
What is
a lead? A lead is the beginning of a news story; it conveys the
main idea in a few words to several paragraphs.
What is
a direct news lead? A direct news lead
is the first paragraph or two of a hard news story. The direct news lead gives the most important
facts, the 5
Ws and an H, about the story.
What are
the 5 Ws and an H?The 5Ws and an H are a direct news lead, so named because it answers
most of the questions readers ask:
Who? What? Where? When? Why?
and How?
The organization of a news story is very important. It gives the reader information that explains
the lead. It tells the story in a logical
sequence. The sequence in which
information is presented in most news stories is called the inverted
pyramid.
What
Is An Inverted Pyramid?
LEAD
MOST
IMPORTANT
DETAILS
LESS
IMPORTANT
DETAILS
LEAST
IMPORTANT
DETAILS
Fig. 1
The Inverted Pyramid
Organization Pattern (JM 123)
Inverted pyramid structure
looks like a pyramid turned upside down.
The top-heavy inverted pyramid implies that the heavy information, the
foundation, is at the top of the story.
Figure 1 graphically shows the inverted pyramid.
The
inverted pyramid organizes information from most important to least important.
· The majority of news stories are written in inverted pyramid style.
· Readers are comfortable with it.
·
They can
extract information quickly from a story organized in inverted pyramid style.
· The style makes it easy for editors
who must place the stories on the pages to shorten them to fit smaller spaces.
·
It is also a logical thinking pattern for reporters.
For more information on
Writing newspaper
articles, including writing leads, the 5Ws and 1 H,
Consult the textbook, Journalism
Matters
·
Section 3 Writing the News pp.111-22,
particularly,
·
Chapter 6 Writing a News Story
pp.112-123
For more information on
· writing
newspaper editorials:
§ Chapter 11 Editorials pp. 248-62
· writing
newspaper columns and reviews:
§ Chapter 12 Column Writing and Reviewing pp. 263-83
Evaluation/Rubrics Evaluation/Rubrics:
|
Developing 10 |
Competent 20 |
Accomplished 30 |
Exemplary 40 |
Score |
Follows journalism
conventions of news article format (hard news, soft news, feature, editorial,
or column) |
Includes 5Ws and an H, adequate lead |
Includes 5Ws and an H in an attempt at
inverted pyramid (or other newspaper-
appropriate format) order |
Includes 5Ws and an H in an inverted
pyramid (or other newspaper-
appropriate format) order, with the relative importance of all elements
accurately assessed |
Articles together work as a series Establishes strong voice, appropriate to
audience, purpose, and tone of the era as well as to that of the newspaper’s
readership |
|
Knowledge and use of history from texts, independent research,
and Public Policy Analyst |
Refers to information to explain at
least one issue or concept in general terms Relies heavily on information provided
in class without evidence of research |
Relates only major facts to the basic
issues with a fair degree of accuracy Limited use of information from previous
historical knowledge and/or group/individual research |
Accurately presents information and
issue Provides facts related to major issues Shows evidence of use of information
from previous historical knowledge as well as research |
Demonstrates extensive use of historical
knowledge and relates issues to the past and future Provides a variety of facts to explore
major and minor issues and concepts |
|
Grammar, spelling,
usage, mechanics |
Frequent errors, many of which may
confuse the reader |
Some
errors, none of which seriously impeded reader understanding, not adequately
revised and proofread |
Ambitious (varied sentence construction,
etc.) with very few errors |
Virtually no errors Active voice v. passive voice considered
and appropriately used |
|
Communication of ideas |
Only minimal organization Considers only one aspect of problem |
Uses general terms with limited evidence
that may not be entirely accurate |
Deals with major issues and shows some
understanding of relationships |
Gives consideration of more than one
idea or aspect of the problem |
|
Presentation
quality of finished project/error |
Sloppy presentation Frequent errors which impede
understanding Not typed |
Typed Many errors, some of which impede
understanding |
Typed, polished, no errors, shows evidence
of revision, but lackluster presentation |
Newspaper articles are typed in an
appropriate font and really look like newspaper articles of the time
period |
|
The REDSCARE
PROJECT ORAL PRESENTATION Rubric/50 points possible
SCORE VALUE |
10 |
QUALITY OF VISUAL AIDS: Visual aids
should be clear and very large; one should be a graph, map, or chart such as
might appear on Task II of a Regents Exam; the visual aid must help tell
the story to the audience and must be integral to the material presented
overall. |
|
DELIVERY: Fluctuation in volume and inflection should
help to maintain audience interest and emphasize high points; mistakes should
be few and minor—and recovery quick; eye contact should build and hold
attention with all parts of audience |
|
STRENGTH OF MATERIAL: The purpose
and subject of the presentation should be clear; pertinent examples, relevant
information, and facts and/or statistics from visuals as well as from presentation
of content should inform the presentation. |
|
AWARENESS OF AUDIENCE and
PROFESSIONALISM: Oral presentation should increase audience’s understanding and
knowledge of topic as evidenced by the level and quality of audience response
throughout the question- and- answer as well as throughout the presentation. |
|
ORGANIZATION: Major ideas
should be summarized in such a manner as to increase the audience’s
understanding of these. The story should be told by weaving incidents,
details, description and significance—as well as facts and statistics—throughout. |
|
N.Y.C. Standards /N.Y.S. Regents Themes:
The tasks of this
webquest not only meet a variety of New York City performance and New York
State learning standards at the highest levels, they also reinforce content and
skills assessed on two New York State Regents administered at the conclusion of
11th grade.
The tasks of this
webquest provide practice for Task II of the N.Y.S. Regents in English Language
Arts.
The tasks of this
webquest provide review of the following Key Themes and Concepts for the N.Y.S.
Regents in American History and Government*:
Change
Why did
the
Foreign
Policy
How did
the
Constitutional
Principles
How did
the fear of communism lead to violations of some people’s civil rights in the
*Note: These themes are copied verbatim from Brief Review in Untied States History and
Government—the standard Regents review book issued to students.
Students wishing further to review explicitly for the
Regents Examination should refer to Section 2 “Peace with Problems 1945-1960”
pp.267-89, especially pp. 275-77. Regents
questions referring directly to this era may be found on pp. 278-283.
The tasks of this
webquest address the following
E1
c. Read and comprehend informational materials.
E2 Writing
a. Produce a report of information.
E3 Speaking, Listening, and Viewing
b. Participate in group meetings.
c. Prepare and deliver an individual
presentation.
E4 Conventions, Grammar, and Usage of the
English Language
a. Independently and habitually demonstrate an
understanding of the rules of the English language in written and oral work.
b. analyze and subsequently revise work to
improve its clarity and effectiveness.
E6 Public Documents
a. Critique public documents with an eye to
strategies common in public discourse
b. Produce functional documents appropriate to an
audience and purpose.
The tasks of this
webquest address all four of the following New York State Learning Standards
For English Language Arts, and at The Commencement Level where indicated with
bullets;
Standard
1: Students will read, write, listen,
and speak for information and understanding.
Students:
·
interpret
and analyze complex informational texts and presentations, including technical
manuals, professional journals, newspaper and broadcast editorials, electronic
networks, political speeches and debates, and primary source material in their
subject are courses
·
synthesize
information from diverse sources and identify complexities and discrepancies in
the information
·
use a
combination of techniques (e.g. previewing, use of advanced organizers,
structural cues) to extract information from texts
·
make
distinctions about the relative value and significance of specific data, facts,
and ideas
·
make
perceptive and well developed connections to prior knowledge
·
evaluate
writing strategies and presentation features that affect interpretation of the
information.
Students:
·
write
and present research reports, feature articles, and thesis/support papers on a
variety of topics related to all school subjects
·
present
a controlling idea that conveys an individual perspective and insight into the
topic
·
use a
wide range of organizational patterns such as chronological, logical (both
deductive and inductive), cause and effect, and comparison/contrast
·
support
interpretations and decisions about relative significance of information with
explicit statement, evidence, and appropriate argument
·
revise
and improve early drafts by restructuring, correcting errors, and revising for
clarity and effect
·
use
standard English skillfully, applying established rules and conventions for
presenting information and making use of a wide range of grammatical
constructions and vocabulary to achieve an individual style that communicates
effectively.
Standard
2: Students will read, write, listen,
and speak for literary response and expression.
2. Speaking and writing for literary
response involves presenting interpretations, analyses, and reactions to the
content and language of a text. Speaking
and writing for literary expression involves producing imaginative texts that
use language and text structures that are inventive and often multilayered.
Students:
·
present
responses to and interpretations of works of recognized literary merit with
references to the principal features of the genre, the period, and literary
tradition, and drawing on their personal experiences and knowledge.
·
produce
literary interpretations that explicate the multiple layers of meaning.
·
write
original pieces in a variety of literary forms, correctly using the conventions
of the genre and using structure and vocabulary to achieve an effect
·
use standard
English skillfully and with an individual style.
Standard
3: Students will read, write, listen,
and speak for critical analysis and evaluation.
1. Listening and reading to analyze and evaluate
experiences, ideas, information, and issues requires using evaluative criteria from a variety of perspectives and
recognizing the difference in evaluations based on different sets of criteria.
Students:
·
analyze,
interpret, and evaluate ideas, information, organization, and language of a
wide range of general and technical texts and presentations across subject
areas, including technical manuals, professional journals, political speeches, and
literary criticism
2. Speaking
and writing critical analysis and evaluation requires presenting opinions and
judgments on experiences, ideas, information, and issues clearly, logically,
and persuasively with reference to specific criteria on which the opinion or
judgment is based.
Students:
·
present
orally and in writing well-developed analysis of issues, ideas, and texts,
explaining the rationale for their positions and analyzing their positions from
a variety of perspectives in such forms as formal speeches, debates,
thesis/support papers, literary critiques, and issues analyses.
Standard
4: Students will read, write, listen, and speak for social interaction
The tasks of this
webquest address all five of the
Standard 1: History of the Untied States and
Students will use a variety of intellectual
skills to demonstrate their understanding of major ideas, eras, themes,
developments, and turning pints in the history of the
1. The study of
Students:
·
analyze the development of American culture,
explaining how ideas, values, beliefs, and traditions have changed over time
and how they unite all Americans
·
describe the evolution of American democratic
values and beliefs as expressed in the Declaration of Independence, the New
York State Constitution, the United States Constitution, the Bill of Rights,
and other important historical documents.
2. Important ideas, social and cultural values,
beliefs, and traditions from New York State and United States history
illustrate the connections and interaction of people and events across time and
from a variety of perspectives.
Students:
·
develop hypotheses about important events,
eras, or issues in
·
examine how the Constitution,
·
analyze the
3. Study about the major social, political,
economic, cultural, and religious developments in
Students:
·
research and analyze the major themes and
development in
·
Prepare essays and oral reports about the
important social, political, economic, scientific, technological, and cultural
developments, issues, and events from
·
Understand the interrelationships between
world events and developments in
4. The skills of historical analysis include
the ability to: explain the significance of historical evidence; weigh the
importance, reliability, and validity of evidence; understand the concept of multiple causation; understand the importance
of changing and competing interpretations of different historical developments.
Students:
·
Analyze historical narratives about key events
in
·
Consider different historians’ analyses of the
same event or development in Untied States history to understand how different
viewpoints and/or frames of reference influence historical interpretations
·
Evaluate the validity and credibility of
historical interpretations of important events or issues in
Standard 2: World History
Students will use a variety of intellectual
skills to demonstrate their understanding of major ideas, eras, themes,
developments, and turning points in world history and examine the broad sweep
of history from a variety of perspectives.
Section 3: Geography
Students will use a variety of intellectual
skills to demonstrate their understanding of the geography of the
interdependent world in which we live—local, national, and global—including the
distribution of people, places, and environments over the Earth’s surface.
Standard 4: Economics
Students will use a variety of intellectual
skills to demonstrate their understanding of how the united States and other
societies develop economic systems and associated institutions to allocate
scarce resources, how major decision-making units function in the United States
and other national economies, and how an economy solves the scarcity problem
through market and nonmarket mechanisms.
Standard 5: Civics, Citizenship, and Government
Students will use a variety of intellectual skills
to demonstrate their understanding of the necessity for establish governments;
the governmental system of the United States and other nations; the United
States Constitution; the basic civic values of American constitutional
democracy; and the rules, rights, and responsibilities of citizenship,
including avenues of participation.
1. The study of civics, citizenship, and
government involves learning about political systems; the purposes of
government and civic life; and the differing assumptions help by people across
time and place regarding power , authority, governance, and laws.
2. The state and federal governments
established by the Constitutions of the United States and the State of New York
embody basic civic values (such as justice, honesty, self-discipline, due
process, equality, majority rule with respect for minority rights, and respect
for self, others, and property), principles, and practices and establish a
system of shared and limited government.
4. The study of civics and citizenship
requires the ability to probe ideas and assumptions, ask and answer analytical
questions, take a skeptical attitude toward questionable arguments, evaluate
evidence, formulate rational conclusions, and develop and refine participatory
skills.
Works Cited Conclusion Works Cited:
Works Cited
Appleby,
Joyce, Alan Brinkley, Albert S. Broussard, James M. McPherson, Donald A.
Ritchie, and The National Geographic
Society. The American Vision.
Glencoe/McGraw-Hill, 2003.
Bartels,
Laura. McCarthyism and the Red Scare.
Webquest.
http://www.coe.unt.edu/TeacherTools/webquests/mccarthyism/mccarthyism.htm.
Bowes,
John S. Miriam Greenblatt, and
Boyer,
Paul S., Clifford E. Clark, Jr., Joseph F. Kett, Neal Salisbury, Harvard Sitkoff,
and
Nancy Woloch. The
Enduring Vision: A History of the American People. 3rd ed.
Briggs,
Bonnie Anne and Catherine Fish Petersen.
Brief Review in
and
Government.
Cayton,
Andrew, Elizabeth Isreals Perry, and Allan M. Winkler.
the
Present.
---.
CNN-Interactive.
Cold War. Website. A CNN Perspectives
Series. Episode 6: “Reds.”
Webpage. 1998. http://www.cnn.com/SPECIALS/cold.war/episodes/06/index.html.
E.M.C.
Paradigm. Literature and the Language
Arts: The American Tradition.2nd ed. The
E.M.C. Masterpiece Series.
Evans,
Harold. The American Century.
Friedman,
Jesse. “The Fight for
Collection:
Entertaining Stories, Informative Reports.
5th
rev. 3rd ed. 1 June 2003 http://www.mccarthy.cjb.net/.
Herblock,
Bob. “I Can’t Do This To Me.” Political
Cartoon. 1954.
Rpt. in Boyer et al., Enduring Vision.
Lacy,
Susan. PBS American Masters: Elia Kazan. The Master List. 1995-2000. 7 July
2004.
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmansters/databse/kazan_e.html.
McCutcheon,
Randall, James Schaffer and Kathryn T. Stofer.
Journalism Matters.
McKinley,
Jesse. “A
Miller,
Arthur. The Crucible. 1953. Rpt. in Prentice
Hall: Literature and the American
Tradition.
---. The
Crucible. 1953. Performance by The
Repertory Theatre of
Center featuring Robert Foxworth, Pamela
Payton-Wright, and Stuart Pankin. Audiocassette. Rec.1972. Caedmon, 1998.
---. “Why I Wrote The Crucible: An Artist’s Answer to Politics.” The New Yorker 7 &
21 Oct.
1996+. http://teachers.sduhsd.net/mcunningham/why_i_wrote.htm.
Mills,
Michael. “HUAC AND Censorship Changes.”
Web page. Classic Films. Website.
adapted from Basinger, Jeaaine. American
Cinema: One Hundred years of Filmmaking, 1994. 1995. http://www.moderntimes.com/palace/huac.htm/
Potter,
Charles. “The Rise of Joseph
McCarthy.” Days of Shame. 1965. Rpt. in
Pathways: Teacher Resources.
Prentice
Hall Literature: The American Experience. Paramount ed.
Prentice Hall, 1994.
Reese,
Michael. “The Cold War and Red Scare in
Project for Washington Schools Developed
by The Center for the Study of the
Tripod. Joseph McCarthy Timeline. http://huac.tripod.com/.