The
Lamb's Chapel v. Center Moriches Decision:
The US Supreme Court reversed the decision. They ruled that: 1) the district's
denial of permission to show the film was a violation of the First Amendment
speech clause given that,: a) the district permitted the use of school property
for social or civic purposes; b) there was no suggestion that the film would not
constitute such a use; c) permission had been denied solely because the film
dealt with an otherwise permissible subject from a religious standpoint; 2) it
would not be a violation of the First Amendment's establishment of religion
clause to permit the church to show the film and; 3) the district's denial could
not be justified on the grounds that: a) the churches use of school property
would lead to threats of public unrest and even violence, or b) the purpose of
the board's access rules was to promote the interests of the public in general
rather than sectarian or other private interests.
You have now completed the
Lamb's Chapel v. Center Moriches analysis using the Project LEGAL method.If you wish
to investigate this case in further detail, CompuLEGAL has created
Follow Up Questions
that identify some of the issues it raises. You may also want to read the entire
Lamb's Chapel v. Center Moriches decision.
If you are done with this case and wish to examine a new case, you should
return to the CompuLEGAL Database.
You may also return to the Project LEGAL Homepage to find a
list of legal links, to use Public Policy Analyst, or if you are enrolled in one
of Project LEGAL's programs, to Ask-A-Legal-Eagle your legal question!