Here is a breakdown of the All Stars (including replacements) by team:
 
| Team | Pos. | All Stars | Players | 
| The Jerichoholics  | 1st | (3) | Javier Báez, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Trevor Megill | 
| RBIed For Her Pleasure | 2nd | (7) | Jazz Chisholm Jr.,
  Riley Greene, Byron Buxton, Shohei Ohtani, Freddy Peralta, Edwin Díaz, Carlos
  Rodon | 
| Gods Do Not Answer
  Letters  | 3rd | (6) | Cal Raleigh, Pete Alonso,
  Steven Kwan, Brendan Donovan, Jacob deGrom, Maikel Garcia | 
| The Counts  | 4th | (6) | Francisco Lindor, Robbie Ray, Logan Webb, Brandon
  Lowe, Julio Rodríguez, Joe Ryan | 
| Vertiginous
  Spelunkers | 5th | (5) | Alejandro Kirk, Eugenio Suárez, Tarik Skubal, Aroldis Chapman, Isaac
  Paredes | 
| I Wish Monkeys
  Could Skype | 6th | (7) | José Ramírez, Elly
  De La Cruz, Aaron Judge, Kyle Stowers, Jason Adam, Andrew Abbott, David
  Peterson | 
| The Konerkos  | 7th | (7) | Hunter Goodman,
  Jonathan Aranda, Ketel Marte, Bobby Witt Jr., Gleyber
  Torres, Junior Caminero, Jacob Misiorowski | 
| Lafayette
  Reservoir Dogs | 8th | (7) | Vladimir Guerrero Jr.,
  Paul Skenes, Garrett Crochet, Andrés Muñoz, Jeremy Peña, MacKenzie
  Gore, Carlos Estevez | 
| Gang Green | 8th | (5) | Will Smith, Bryan
  Woo, Josh Hader, Yusei Kikuchi, Randy Arozarena | 
| Vermicious Knids | 10th | (5) | Jacob Wilson, Kyle
  Tucker, Max Fried, Chris Sale, Zach McKinstry | 
| Canadian Bacon | 11th | (4) | Manny Machado, Fernando Tatis
  Jr, Randy Rodríguez, Matthew Boyd | 
| Amandier Birds  | 12th | (5) | Freddie Freeman, Zack
  Wheeler, Corbin Carroll, Robert Suarez, Casey Mize | 
| Greased
  Lightning  | 13th | (5) | James Wood, Kris Bubic, Clayton Kershaw, Hunter Brown, Alex Bregman | 
| Low End Theory | 14th | (3) | Pete
  Crow-Armstrong, Ryan O’Hearn, Drew Rasmussen | 
| Cooper’s Bloopers | 15th | (2) | Matt Olson, Ronald
  Acuña Jr. | 
| FREE AGENT |  | (2) | Shane Smith,
  Adrian Morejon |