Argument #1
The Court should decide in favor of Smith (the mother). She has a right to have an abortion. Besides, the father of her unborn child is married to another woman and it is unlikely that Smith and the father would get back together.
Argument #2
The Court should rule in favor of the afther in this case and prevent Smith from getting an abortion. The unborn child is his as well as hers and he should have a voice in whether that child is aborted or not.